On Saturday evening, April 20th, fifty loyal friends of Senator Timothy D. Sullivan tendered him a dinner and a magnificent silver loving cup, in the private dining room of the Hoffman House. The menu was an elaborate one and the event will long be remembered by those present.
Hon. Timothy P. Sullivan acted as toastmaster and Congressman Sulzer made the presentation speech (to “him we love) in his usual eloquent, brilliant and felicitious way. Other speeches of congratulation were made by Hon. Daniel E. Finn, Hon. George F. Roesch, Hon. Julius Harburger and Hon. Patrick F. Trainor.

The cup was a most magnificent affair standing over six feet high, solid silver, with a base of onyx and gold handles. The weight of the cup is 750 ounces. It has the likeness of Senator Sullivan on one side and St. Tammany on the other, with the names of the donors engraved on the base, as follows: Hon. Thomas F. Grady, Hon. William B. Calvert, David Ryan, Samuel Kahn, George J. Kraus, Thomas L. Foley, Lawrence Mulligan, Hon. Timothy P. Sullivan. Michael C. Padden, Hon. Benjamin Hoffman, George Considine, John Considine, Martin Engel, Thomas J. Brady, Louis Leavitt, John Fitzgerald. John A. Dooner, D. F Mullaney, Frank Farrell, Joseph Vendig, Andrew J. Hughes, Manny Monheimer, Manny Chappelle, Hon. John B. Sexton, William H. Leonard.
“The City of New York," was the toast Justice George F. Roesch responded to. Hon. Julius Harburger talked of the Eleventh District and Hon. P. F. Trainor on “Unity.” Solid silver souvenir busts of Senator Sullivan, framed in Mexican onyx, were kept as mementoes of the occasion which Mr. Louis W. Olms. who had charge of the service. said eclipsed anything in his twenty-six years’ of experience. Here is a picture of the cup and the names of Senator Sullivan’s guests.
T. P. Sullivan, toastmaster. John C. Fitzgerald. William Sulzer. Alderman Fleck. F. J. Farrell. Joseph Dunn. John A. Dooner. Nicholas J Hayes.
Thomas J. Brady. William H. Leonard. Manny Chappeile. George F. Roesch. Julius Kaufmann. Isaac Fromme. Samuel Kahn. Louis Leavltt.
P. H. Sullivan. Eugene D. Wood. Lawrence Mulligan. P. F. Trainor. John B. Sexton. David Ryan. Thomas F. Foley. Benjamin Hoffman. “Battery Dan" Finn. D. F. Mullaney. Julius Harburger. George J. Kraus. Percival E. Nagle. Maurice Mannheimer. Dr. M. B. Feeney. Joseph H. Vendig. John J. White. George Considine. John Consldine. Martin Engel.
Source: The Tammany Times - 29th April 1901
Trev.